# Addressing Mixed Manning Challenges on Ships: An Unfinished Business for the Maritime Industry.

- Link: https://williamamanhyia.com/addressing-mixed-manning-challenges-on-ships-an-unfinished-business-for-the-maritime-industry/
- Published: 2025-10-04T20:52:51+00:00
- Author: Capt. William Amanhyia

At the time when recruitment in the maritime industry was waning in the traditional
maritime countries, there were several calls about “where the next batch of seafarers
was going to come from”. Some of us were of the view that the next batch of seafarers
was going to come from South of the Suez, was going to be brown-skinned, and would
have wooly and kinky hair.

As time went on, a distinct pattern emerged in the industry’s traditional workforce
demographics. This created some challenges in the industry that have up till now
not been fully addressed. Some years back I wrote an article on this issue that 
received wide attention, mainly because it was the first of such articles written
on the issue by a serving shipboard officer who has had first-hand experience working
in that new environment. One such significant review was in the Apostolatus Maris
of the Catholic News Service, April 17, 2002. The full article which was published
in January 2002 in the “Seaways”, the official journal of the Nautical Institute
is posted here with special permission from the Nautical Institute..

## Managing Cultural Diversity

#### Captain William Amanhyia, MSc, MNI

Shipmaster, Pacific International Lines, Singapore

_Currently slightly, more. than 50 per cent of the world fleet is mixed manned, 
mainly with crew originating from different countries in the developing world. This
shift in the maritime industry’s traditional labor market demographics has resulted
in the creation, of a new, diverse maritime workforce that has now become largely
more multi-cultural than ever before. This, perhaps, represents one of the most 
significant changes facing the maritime industry today._ 

As a result of the increase in racial heterogeneity on ships, working in a cross-
cultural environment has become a way of life for most seafarers. They need therefore,
to be made aware of the challenges and opportunities they are likely to face in 
such an environment. With more than half of the world fleet now mixed manned, managing
cultural diversity can no longer be thought of as an organizational issue alone 
but also an industrial responsibility.  Cross-cultural issues if they are not properly
managed. provoke negative perceptions and reactions, and the principle underlying
the management of diversity is to ensure that differences are acknowledged, valued
and appreciated.

Two recent incidents I was involved in on mixed manned ships highlight some of the
cross-cultural issues that require appreciation of cultural differences in order
for them to be dealt with effectively. The first involved my mate, who wanted to
know what should be done to an officer found having a beer with the bosun in the
officer’s cabin after working hours.

 

This incident, depending on one’s cultural background, might seem trivial or could
have serious consequences on what some culture might interpret as discipline. The
second involved a third officer who. during maneuvering out of port through heavy
traffic failed to draw the master’s attention when the vessel strayed off the intended
track and closed in uncomfortably to an island.  He could not give any reasonable
explanation why he failed to inform the master. who had the con at that time. This
is also a familiar type of incident involving difficulty in getting, information
feedback from some nationalities when their junior officers fear to report faults.

 

Another reason for addressing cultural diversity is that the maritime industry has
now focused on the human aspects of operations as a means through which declining
performance standards in the industry can be improved. One issue under this is shipboard
habitability standards which have been found to impact on the crews’ sense of wellbeing.
Shipping organizations are required to create a conducive environment that can nurture
a more productive working relationship among a crew having diverse, and often different
core identities, an environment in which shipboard work is less likely to be hindered
by obstacles such as conflict and misunderstanding caused by human differences. 
Organizations’ success however, in developing this ideal environment in which cultural
awareness and valuing of differences is a hallmark, can only be an outgrowth of 
the industry’s total endeavor. and serious commitment to approach cultural diversity
in a positive way. 

### **Potential benefits **

There are several areas in the industry where cultural diversity’s potential if 
properly harnessed, can prove beneficial.  For example, apart from the obvious potential
that a culturally diverse workforce with different perspectives can contribute to
the organization’s creativity  the potential exists  to use cultural diversity to
improve some aspects of  habitability standards on board. One well documented problem
faced by the industry is the effect of social isolation on crew as a result of fast
vessel turnaround. Its negative impact on seafarers’ lives is now of major concern
in the industry. Properly harnessed, I believe the rich cultural background of a
mixed crew can provide the answer to this.

The company I work for operates mixed  manned ships. Six nationalities on a ship
with a 23-man crew is the norm. My present ship has nine nationalities and with 
an average port stay of eight hours, a run ashore is a luxury we barely can afford.
However the rich cultural mix on board probably provides a more relaxing environment
than a run ashore could do. By encouraging social mixing, there is  always something
new to learn, “something to keep one’s mind occupied’. Thanks to my Polish chief
engineer for example, I now know a bit more about Polish history and why Lech Walesa
was a good electrician but a ‘lousy president’ (his own words), My second engineer,
from the former Yugoslavia, is learning how to eat curry, having the usual problems
with foreign food, but thoroughly enjoyiug himself with what he terms ‘all the exotic
eastern cuisine’. As I am preparing this article, my two Indian cadets are preparing
for the coming Indian festival of colors; and when “one visits the crew mess in 
the evenings, one is sure to come across some fantastic national costumes, from 
lhe Indonesians in their fez hats and colorful batiks, probably with a prayer mat
under their arms, to the Burmese in their loincloths and the Sikhs in their colorful}
turbans, all relaxing and chatting after a hard day’s work

It is also a fact that some nationalities, when serving on mixed-manned ships, are
able to spend longer periods at sea without any apparent emotional problems. This
might be a useful facet of mixed crewing when considering ways and means to reduce
number of crew changes. With crew costs averaging about 40 per cent of operating
costs, reducing the number of crew changes through crew spending a longer period
on the ship might bring about substantial cost savings. This is an area that might
be worth investigating.

An enormous amount of technological ingenuity has been deployed in the industry 
to make cost savings, such as shorter turnaround and smaller crews, possible. Most
have impacted negatively on the life of seafarers in social terms. I believe that
even if a small part of such ingenuity could also be deployed to research into the
potential inherent in cultural diversity, it might enable the industry to capitalize
on the power of diversity Unfortunately several factors have combined and reinforced
each other to prevent such attempts.

### **B****arriers to change**

‘The increase in international trans-border labor mobility has taken place only 
within the past few decades. Cultural diversity issues are therefore relatively 
new in industries and even in the USA, which probably has the largest multi-cultural
workforce ashore, it is only in the last few decades that cultural diversity has
become a management issue.  It is, therefore, not surprising that the critical mass
needed to trigger off the incentive to address a new issue such as cultural diversity
has not yet been attained.

In addition, many shipping organizations in the traditional maritime countries have
only recently been significantly affected by the increase in racial heterogeneity
on ships ‘The pattern that emerged during the demographic changes in the industry’s
workforce has caused mixed manning to become synonymous with third world crewing.
Since third world crewing is perceived in the traditional maritime countries as 
cheap competition from the developing  world, and the industry’s policies and practices
have historically been influenced and dictated by these same traditional maritime
nations, there hasn’t been much incentive to address issues connected with mixed
manning

Reinforcing this factor is the fact that. because people’s inadequate knowledge 
of human differences causes them to regard ‘otherness’ or difference as deficient
and substandard, the norms inherent in the new workforce have been perceived as 
obstacles rather than us options Mixed manning, bas therefore taken on a symbolic
meaning and now comes pre-loaded with people’s individual perceptions and biases.
The first step, therefore, will be to understand the concept of culture and its 
influence on racioethnicity, as the interaction of the-two is what leads to cultural
diversity in workplaces.

### **Influence of culture**

Culture is a code through which patterns of conduct are communicated and deciphered
through the use of words, gestures and symbols. It is acquired early in life from
the society in which we are brought up. Professor Geert Hofstede, the pioneer ia
the analyzing the relationships between organizational actions and cultural beliefs,
describes it as ‘the software of the mind’ because much like a computer’s operating
system, culture provides us with an essential code by which we make sense of the
world. Anthropologists have identified over 70 variables, or cultural universals,
elements found in all cultures and through which characteristics distinct to a particular
culture are manifested. Some of those elements are time, orientation, power differential
and modes of communication. The anthropologist E.J. Kolde, who studied these cultural
variables, produced a table of the elements and how they vary across cultures. Part
of the table is shown below.

  |

**Element**

  |

**Culture A**

  |

**Culture B**

  |  
 |

Verbal communication  

  |

Explicative

  |

Implicative

  |  
 |

Non verbal communication

  |

Passive

  |

Active

  |  
 |

Modes of thinking

  |

Pragmatic

  |

Universalistic

  |  
 |

Personal orientation

  |

Individualistic

  |

Collectivistic

  |  
 |

Time orientation

  |

Intense

  |

Casual

  |  
 |

Leadership style

  |

Time-Oriented

  |

People-oriented

  |  
 |

Power distance

  |

Short

  |

Distant

  |

#### **Table 1:  Cultural Variables**

People’s racial and ethnic background will therefore instill in them values and 
these which will be different for each race or culture determines an individual’s
attitude to work and to authority and will also influence work behavior.

### Relationship Issues

Most of the issues concerned with ¢toss – cultural relationships have to do with
factors such as power relationships, norms of participation and decision-making 
as well as performance appraisal. Some of the earliest research on the influence
of race ethnicity on work behavior in the maritime industry was carried out by Professor
David Moresby. Moresby, of the Institute of Marine Studies, Plymouth University,
applied the works environmental preferential schedule (WEPS} to the maritime industry
and came up with a matrix of behavior exhibited by personnel from some of the maritime
industry’s major labor-producing countries (see table 2 opposite)

Moresby used the power differential index (PDI) and the rule orientation index (
ROI) both developed by Hofstede as indices in bis matrix. The PDI is a measure of
the hierarchical distance that exists , between managers and their subordinates.
Managers from high PDI cultures exercise a great deal of power and are apt to give
directives rather than seek broad participation in decision-making. Subordinates
are required to show due deference to their bosses and are less inclined to speak
out. Managers from low PDI cultures on the other hand are more inclined to speak
out and to participate in decision making. The other index, ROI, is a measure of
the tendency to stick to rules. A high ROI indicates a person abides by the rules
even in circumstances when it is against the company’s interest to do so, A low 
ROI indicates that the person concerned generally uses the rules as guidelines. 
A representative sample of the matrix is reproduced opposite : 
Although Moresby’s
work involved only two possible cultural variables, it indicates that culture can
no longer be thought of as some ill defined concept but that its variable dimensions
across cultures also

  |

 

  |

**HIGH PDI**

  |

**LOW PDI**

  |  
 |

**HIGH ROI**

  |

India, Singapore, Malaysia

France, Greece, S. American

  |

West Germany

  |  
 |

**LOW ROI**

  |

Philippines, West Africa, Japan

East Africa

  |

USA,  NW Europe, Canada

Scandinavia

  |

 

### Table 2 : Application of WEPS to senior ship officers and middle levels shipping managers

**Source: Moresby**

.

### **The mate’s question**

 For example the mate’s question and the junior officer’s reluctance to take part
in decision making, referred to at the start of this article, have to do with the
power differential index. For someone who comes from a high PDI culture, where managers
are expected to maintain a great hierarchical distance from subordinates, an officer
does not sit down to have a drink with a rating’  Such a mate will perceive what
the officer and bosun did as wrong The officer and bosun from a low PDI culture,
on the other hand, may see nothing wrong with this.  Further problems may arise 
when a performance appraisal has to be done for an officer after an incident like
this.

 In one case, a master was badly assaulted by an otherwise docile Burmese crew because
he reported to his company that his Burmese mate was not assertive enough to maintain
discipline on board The mate was also a Burmese and mingled freely with bis countrymen.
The mate was subsequently dismissed from the vessel and the rest of the crew reacted
wildly The master had misunderstood the collectivistic culture of the Burmese and
their tendency to form support groups on mixed manned ships. The Burmese crew. in
turn, also misunderstood the master’s culture which demands a hierarchical distance
to be maintained between officers and ratings as racial discrimination. This unfortunately
is a common occurrence on mixed manned ships.  Performance appraisal is a very important
function of senior management on ships. It is needed to identify crews’ training
needs and career mobility If not done fairly, not only is it harmful to the organization’s
human resource management plan but it is also bad for morale on the ship. Because
much of the appraisal methods used on ships are subjective and therefore highly 
susceptible to culture biased errors recognition of this avoids the creation of 
diversity tensions and enable senior officers to recognize that what they see is
highly colored from their cultural perspective. Knowing this enables them to approach
appraisal with an unbiased mind.  Unfortunately, the industry’s current major labor-
producing countries are places where cultural influence is very strong. India, producing
most of the officers on nixed manned ships as a result of their social caste system,
is characterized by a high PDI and ROI culture.  The Philippines, producing most
of the ratings has n relatively lower PDI and ROI rating, and has a collectivistic
and’ easy going culture.  What happens when officers from these two countries serve
on the same ship and need to do performance appraisal of each other?  Obviously 
unless the cultural differences are understood and appreciated, any such assessment
will be severely flawed and yet it is currently the norm in the industry. The some
happens when you have Chinese, Burmese or Africans serving together on the same 
ship. Without cultural differences being appreciated problems of such nature are
bound to arise. 

 

### **Cultural antagonisms  **

Another important issue is the fact that some nationalities just do not get along
well together on ships. Although this is well known in the maritime industry, racial
sensitivity has prevented this from being addressed or researched.  however if mixed
manning is to serve the industry as well as it should, then this issue will need
to be openly addressed. Currently it appears that Indonesian and Filipino crew do
not mix well at all. The same is true with Indian officers and Chinese crew, and
to a certain extent, a covert uneasiness bordering on antipathy, that has traditionally
existed between Indians and Africans. When nationalities from these countries serve
together o. ships, a lot of racial diversity tension is created. This cultural antagonism
needs to be properly researched into and addressed, since some of these countries
currently supply the bulk of the industry’s labor. When crew are made aware that
such issues do exist, they get to accept that this does not in anyway reflect on
competency of the nationals involved but are rather the result of cultural differences

The third mate’s case also illustrates a very serious effect of cultural influence
on critical shipboard operations. The third mate from a high PDI culture was just
not used to speaking out. In his culture, junior officers may feel they are not 
in a position to voice out their doubts, and may well. become a weak link in a chajn
that may eventually lead to an accident if not recognised in time and dealt with
appropriately. This has been observed to be a common problem nowadays on mixed manned
ships, and instructors from bridge team resource management courses haye also made
similar observations.  Other variables also may inpact negatively on critical shipboard
operations, and need to be properly researched into.

### ** Conclusion **

While change is an inevitable part of organizational life, it is those organizations
that are able to capitalise on this that survive.  Charles Darwin once  said, ‘it
is not the strongest of the species that survive, nor the most intelligent, but.
the one most responsive to change.’ The, maritime indusiry is now faced with a multicultural
workforce which require organizations to provide an environment that enables the
crew to operate comfortably within it.  In order to do that, awareness of national
characteristics needs to improve overall in the industry, This requires providing
diversity training for scafarers so they can do away with the subtle assumptions
that differences equate to deficiencies, an assumption that has been the root cause
of much racial tension on mixed manned ships.

Cultural diversity being a rclatively new  field, there is not much information 
available on tbe subject, especially that pertaining to the maritime industry, to
assist senior officers on mixcd manned  ships. The maritime industry is also perhaps
the industry with the most  culturally diverse workforce right now. Extensive research
is therefore needed in this area. In this respect, the Nautical Institute with its
diverse membership is best placed to take the initiative, and I believe this is 
an area that needs to be given priority..

**References**

 1. Hofstede, Geert. (1991) _Cultures and Organizations. Software of the Mind_, McGraw
 2. Kolde, E,J. _Environment of International Business,_ Boston: Kent Publishing
 3. David. ‘_Cross – cultural issues in the manning of ships’_, Bimco Bulletin ,2/9

 *  
